Update: Epson Durabrite and UltraChrome and 3rd party Pigment Based inks DO NOT SUCK for button making.
(You're welcome to keep reading this long-winded rant about the suckiness of inkjet, but please keep in mind that I wrote this before I became fully educated on the wonders of Pigment Inks and the following is only in reference to Dye based inkjet)
I know, I know. This is very bad news. On the upside it doesn't really affect every button maker out there. Those of you printing photo buttons and things that will for the most part be kept indoors, are fine using inkjet. But for those of you making buttons that are to be worn on the clothes, the buttons need to be able to withstand moisture, rain, or even a trip through the wash. All things inkjet just can't do.
Inks are water soluble. Period. It is impossible to create a waterproof inkjet print unless you laminate it. Inkjet prints are much much more susceptible to sun damage as well - meaning that your amazingly bright Epson colors look like ultra faded crapola after just a few months of wear.It is very tempting to go into business making buttons using an inkjet printer. After all the price is right, the color replication is awesome, and the resolution is impeccable. BUT you have to buy expensive paper to produce the right color and resolution. AND once that amazing color button you just made hits the real world, it runs and looks awful. Even if the design holds up by some miracle, after a while these weird brown stains start to seep in. Some people refer to these stains as "rust." But trust me, that ain't no rust! It's the moisture interacting with the inkjet paper. I have yet to see any of these problems occur on buttons made with a laser printer.
Inkjet Pro's
- Inexpensive
- Beautiful colors
- High resolution
- Expensive paper required to obtain all the pro's
- Water soluble. The colors ruuuuunnnnnn when exposed to moisture
- Browning paper (even the expensive kind when it gets wet, then oxidizes)
- Fades quickly in the sun. (We're talking months, not years folks)
- Prints very slooooooooowly
- No fancy paper required. Regular office paper achieves the same quality.
- Not water soluble. Can withstand normal exposure to moisture just fine.
- Good color longevity even in the sun.
- Prints very fast!
- Acceptable color reproduction
- Expensive initial investment
- Expensive toner refills
- Not very high resolution
So maybe you are still on the fence. Maybe you've seen some inkjet buttons that seem to be holding up. Maybe you've compared the resolution and just can't part with your hi res inkjet. Maybe you've seen the price tag on that laser printer and are still picking your jaw up off the floor. I don't know. But before you go into business using an inkjet printer, think about this:
Your first rush order for 10,000 buttons that you stayed up all night working on so your very best customer could have them for an event the next day, arrives.... wet.... ruined.
or this:
"Hey you know those buttons you made for my store? We'll my customers are all returning them because the colors are all running and faded and there are these brown spots appearing on them. This makes me look really bad and I threw away most of them. Can I have a refund?"
yeah. bad news. get a laser printer. seriously.


































